ITV’s Victoria reigns over BBC’s Are You Being Served? and Porridge revivals

Jenna Coleman as Queen Victoria (left) and Sherrie Hewson as Mrs SlocombeImage copyright

Image caption

Jenna Coleman as Queen Victoria (left) was adult opposite Sherrie Hewson as Mrs Slocombe

Queen Victoria has beaten Mrs Slocombe to a TV ratings climax as ITV’s new royal play drew some-more viewers than BBC One’s reconstruction of classical sitcom Are You Being Served? on Sunday.

Overnight total showed an normal of 5.4 million people watched Jenna Coleman in Victoria, incompatible +1.

Are You Being Served?, in that Sherrie Hewson donned Mrs Slocombe’s pinkish wig, was seen by 5 million viewers.

It was followed by an updated Porridge, that captivated 4.4 million.

Image caption

Jason Watkins’ opening as Mr Humphries divided opinion

‘A pompous half-hour’

The new versions of Are You Being Served? and Porridge are partial of a deteriorate of BBC programmes to symbol a 60th anniversary of a birth of a TV sitcom.

Are You Being Served? creatively ran from 1972 to 1985. The one-off new part was set in 1988.

Loose Women star Hewson played Mrs Slocombe, a impression done famous by Molly Sugden, and Bafta Award leader Jason Watkins starred as Mr Humphries, creatively played by John Inman.

But a uncover was described as a “turgid, perpetual half-hour” by a Daily Telegraph’s TV censor Michael Hogan.

‘A energetic one-off homage’

It had a “lazy faith on lavatorial humour and infrequent misogyny”, he wrote, with Watkins’ opening “the biggest misfire”.

“Watkins is a excellent actor, yet here he was doing a toe-curling reverence act, cartoonishly stay and straining too tough for laughs. It done one conclude Inman’s iconic description even more.”

The Times’ James Jackson was kinder on Watkins. He wrote: “You could pardon him for hidden a show, given a genuine crime here was a uncover itself.”

The Guardian’s Stuart Jeffries described it as “a energetic one-off homage”, yet added: “Thank heavens it’s usually a one-off, though.”

Image caption

Kevin Bishop played Norman Stanley Fletcher’s grandson Nigel in Porridge

The new chronicle of Porridge, meanwhile, was created by Dick Clement and Ian La Frenais, who were behind a original.

Sunday’s part was set in a benefaction day and featured Kevin Bishop as a grandson of Norman Stanley Fletcher, famously played by Ronnie Barker in a 1970s. It got a somewhat improved reception.

The Telegraph’s Michael Hogan wrote: “If one of final night’s one-off revivals is to get a full array – and temperament in mind a new ratings success of Still Open All Hours, we strongly think that is a BBC’s goal – I’d most rather it was this one.

“Porridge left me with an indulgent laugh on my face, rather than an Are You Being Served? cringe.”

X Factor’s total drop

Earlier, ITV’s The X Factor narrowly kick BBC One’s Antiques Roadshow in a timeslot.

The second complement of a talent show’s 13th array was seen by 5.7 million people on ITV during 20:00 BST on Sunday – not including +1 and catch-up.

Antiques Roadshow pulled in 5.6 million, while a final of Robot Wars on BBC Two – that saw Dave Young, Marc Dermott and Ben Bacon delight with Apollo – was watched by 1.4 million.

The ratings for X Factor’s second part were down on a 6.3 million who had tuned in for a initial complement on Saturday night.

Follow us on Twitter @BBCNewsEnts, on Instagram, or if we have a story idea email

Article source: